Blog Layout

Value Focused Insights – Hard Learned Lessons from Gemba

Tim Upchurch

There is an alarming statistic that 90% of lean transformations will fail. According to McKinsey, 74% of private-sector business initiatives will not achieve their objectives. In the public sector, similar types of projects can have failure rates as high as 80%. 

 

At best, your next change initiative has around a 70% chance of failure. How do you change the odds in your favor? 

 

Join Peak Productivity as we provide the answers in our upcoming series of articles, entitled: "Value Focused Insights – Hard Learned Lessons from Gemba".

The Reality

There is an alarming statistic that 90% of lean transformations will fail. According to McKinsey, 74% of private-sector business initiatives will not achieve their objectives. In the public sector, similar types of projects can have failure rates as high as 80%. 

 

These are the complex, large-scale strategic plans we often are a part of in our professional lives. In the beginning, we are all pulled into a large room where we are given promises for all the pain and stress that will be removed from our daily jobs, provided with the customary water bottle emblazed with the approved project name/slogan, and introduced to a fantasy timeline for execution. We are told how everything will be different this time because we are going to be using XXX (insert your favorite buzzword – AI, synergy, deep diving, etc.). On opening day, every fan is excited by the prospect of the coming season. But by the end of that first day, half of us could already be frustrated due to a lack of execution or poor design.   

 

At best, your next change initiative has around a 70% chance of failure. There are a variety of reasons you will not succeed according to the literature.  Every organization’s unique problems are clumped together into 4-6 major categories. 

 

It would be helpful to develop countermeasures for these before you begin, but the literature is written at a very high level and not always relevant or actionable. The conclusions are not specific enough to help you because your situation is unique, and the business landscape constantly changes. But you must do something to achieve financial targets, right? So, millions of dollars and resources will be wasted on the next round of inherently flawed programs.

 

What you need is a way to generate more value, in a manner that is both faster and cheaper.  It is often said that you can only have two of the following: FAST, GOOD, CHEAP. That statement is wrong – it is possible to have all three simultaneously. You will need to think differently about your problem. Even then, it’s not always easy to do. Good news, there are those who know how to crack the code.

 

The Decision

With that issue in mind, Peak Productivity decided to introduce a new series of articles/blogs to provide help on how you can supercharge your improvement initiatives. We will let you in on how to generate multiple returns in value and do so on a budget – both in time and money.

 

These are not just simple guides to follow; they are the blueprints, the profound lessons, the secret sauce, the "aha" moments, and the best tactics/strategies that we have either developed or learned from some very smart people over our 50 years of collective lean working experience. In this series, we will explore lean thinking and improvement scenarios through the PDCA lens, providing you with these best practices, shortcuts, hacks, and force multipliers that have consistently delivered value. 

 

Our goal will be to communicate the deeper level lessons in a way that you can use them effectively today, but without having to spend many years on practice or reflection. We hope to do so in a manner that clearly delivers both fundamental and actionable knowledge for you but allows you to retain the inherent humility that comes with time.   

 

Plan

In the "Plan" phase, we start by unraveling how to generate value through stability. One higher level goal is we want to always support our customers. What better way than to develop stable and robust processes that will consistently achieve the needs of our customers? Everyone has internal and external customers – we need to understand how to effectively meet all demands and requirements, 100% of the time. To achieve that, we will develop hypotheses about our processes. Some of the higher level needs to be addressed will be reliability, quality, flow, and system designs.

 

Do

In the course of fulfilling demand, we will need to continually test our hypotheses. Normal variation and randomness will identify weak points in our systems and create fluctuations in output. To counteract this, we must introduce strong people systems to support our "Do" phase, to effectively react and counter for standard deviations. It's more than just introducing concepts like backing-up someone; it's about developing the chemistry and understanding the unique dynamics that transform a group of individuals into a high-performing team.


  • How and when do they react to adversity? 
  • What is the standard approach to reduce overcorrections? 
  • What is my deliverable?


We will explore detailed strategies for fostering engagement, initiative, collaboration, and a shared commitment to lean excellence. We must uncover the subtle yet powerful elements that enable meaningful cultural shifts. These will become magnified when working across functional and organizational boundaries.

 

Check

As we transition into the "Check" phase, speed of execution becomes our focus. But it isn't just about speed; it's about integrating seamlessly with the “Do” systems for impact. Understand how an action-biased approach, coupled with a strategic sense of urgency, accelerates learning and the improvement process. Dive into strategies for swift, effective tests that stand up to scrutiny. Every data point comes at the cost of valuable resources. We need to make sure our processes can take advantage of and learn from every cycle.


It is vitally important not only to know when to react, but also when NOT to react. Knowing what we think we know is true – testing it to make sure that it is still valid. We need to respect the process, but not be afraid to grab the reins when needed to keep it under control.

 

Act

In the "Act" phase, we unveil the lessons of leverage. It's not just about implementing solutions; it's about strategically placing them for system level leaps in effectiveness. We will explore how targeted improvements, when strategically applied, create a ripple effect, multiplying their impact across the entire value stream.


Staying within the "Act" phase, the focus shifts to the Lean Innovation Process. Discover how to foster an environment where experimentation is not just encouraged but becomes the lifeblood of your lean journey. There is no end to improvement, and we should never rest on our laurels. Learn the art of embracing failures as opportunities for learning and growth. And always make sure you cross the finish line and don’t get distracted with the next thing too early.

 

Conclusion

As we discuss the power of these lessons, we invite you to not just read but to engage, reflect, and apply. Each lesson has been tested in the real world and stood up to the challenge. Stay tuned for the first installment.

 

We appreciate feedback. Please share your thoughts and experiences related to these upcoming lessons in the comments section. Let's build a dynamic repository of insights and wisdom that contributes to the collective understanding of lean principles and continuous improvement. Stay tuned for a series that promises not just knowledge but actionable strategies for transforming your Lean journey.


Peaks and Valleys.....

By Tim Upchurch January 25, 2024
The impact of placing the right person in the right role is nothing short of transformative - both for them and the organization. It aligns with the aspirations of lean, which continually reminds us to promote respect for people as they are the cornerstone for success. If done correctly, it will breed success.
By Annah Godwin January 18, 2024
Have you ever asked someone to explain the concept of Gemba? If you ask for specific details about the Gemba, like who should go to the Gemba, and when to go to the Gemba, did you find variations in their answers? If you push the discussion deeper and ask about the individual’s experience with Gemba, like when they go to Gemba, how long they stay, and what is their purpose for going to the Gemba, what answers did you get? I find that opinions on Gemba can vary a lot from person to person which brings me to the topic for this blog. I want to debunk a few of the misconceptions about it.
By Tim Upchurch December 28, 2023
If you are like most organizations, you have too much rework and/or defects. It should come to no surprise that most processes do not have good standardized work. In theory, this should be very easy to see and deal with, but other things tend to consume our time. As a result of bad quality, we have to make more to meet demand or stop what we're doing and fix something. This puts us behind pace and have to throw more resources to catch up. In some value streams, poor quality can go undetected until much later downstream. In some cases, final quality is hidden from view until right before packing! These firms use inspection only at the end of the process as a catch-all and pay the price. Poor quality moves unnoticed as it travels the value stream, adding significant costs along the way until they decide to deal with it.
By Annah Godwin December 21, 2023
There are many advantages for organizations that have long-time employees. They can bring stability, knowledge, and understanding of the business’ organizational culture and they also have first-hand experience of their day-to-day processes and the products produced. While there are many great things associated with long-term employees, there is one potential pitfall that needs to be acknowledged and watched for. Continue reading this week's blog to learn what the pitfall is.
By Tim Upchurch December 13, 2023
Imagine this scenario: your workplace receives a substantial order, demanding a 35% increase in production for a continuous six-month period, commencing at the end of the next quarter. The knee-jerk reaction for many organizations is to dive headfirst into hiring, adding shifts, and equipment. However, is this the most strategic move, or merely a countermeasure that might lead to a slew of unforeseen challenges?
By Annah Godwin December 7, 2023
Today, companies face a tremendous challenge with staff shortages which should remind companies that people, specifically their employees, are the most valuable resources. Replacing or backfilling vacancies is a long and arduous process with the result not always guaranteeing a great match between the company and the new hire. Companies willing and eager to invest in their employees and appreciate their value and contributions to the company can turn the company-employee relationship into a “win-win”.
By Tim Upchurch November 22, 2023
Great teams make things happen - whether it's pulling a win out at the last minute or beating metrics to save the quarter. Bad teams perform poorly, never seem to "catch a break" and eventually lead to management changes. This is the way. If you are in responsible for a team - there is no bigger expectation than for you to build it into a cohesive force that wins. • What drives the people in your organization and how does your management behavior influence it? • Do you have a group of individuals that only work together when it's favorable for them or do you have a team that is selflessly focused on collective success? • How do you convert a team made up of "ME-people" into "WE-people"? How do you get people to be less about themselves and more about the team? Your approach should be one that transcends individual accomplishments, emphasizing the power of a collaborative and team-centric culture. The good news is it doesn't have to necessarily start with your onboarding or selection process.
By Annah Godwin November 15, 2023
In today’s world of “go, go, go” the idea of stopping is hard to imagine. This same “go, go, go” mentality also applies in the business world. As managers, executives, owners, and employees, we find it difficult to stop, even when it is obvious that we should. This is especially true with defects and the process failures that allow them to occur. In this blog, I will discuss stopping the errors by building processes to prevent defects from getting to the customer.
By Tim Upchurch November 8, 2023
Imagine the stakes: a critical issue surfaces in your value stream, threatening quality, flow, and customer satisfaction. The clock ticks, resources deplete, and every moment the problem remains unsolved, your organization is caught in a costly web of workarounds and compromises. It's all hands-on deck to execute quick and effective problem-solving. So, how does your team meet the challenge and get to true root cause quickly and restore operations back to the normal levels? We'll unravel some common pitfalls —from the blame game, leadership biases and the perilous allure of hearsay and opinions. Join us on this exploration - of why, in your quest for solutions you need to demand a steadfast commitment of prioritizing facts over opinions.
By Annah Godwin November 1, 2023
In this week's blog, we start a new series from Peak Productivity titled, "Value-Focused Insights - Hard-Learned Lessons from Gemba. In it, I discuss the need to spend the time and energy to create a plan that builds efficiency in the design and layout phase of the process, not remove waste after the equipment, flow, and processes are se t.
More Posts
Share by: